The following Big 12 gymnasts have earned All-American honors during the 2023 season. 

2023 NCAA National Championship All-Americans
First Team
Lynnzee Brown, Denver – All-Around, Vault, Floor
Jessica Hutchinson, Denver – All-Around, Floor
Jordan Bowers, Oklahoma – Floor
Katherine LeVasseur, Oklahoma - Vault
Allie Stern, Oklahoma – Vault
Faith Torrez, Oklahoma – Floor
Olivia Trautman, Oklahoma – Vault, Balance Beam
 
Second Team
Rosie Casali, Denver – Uneven Parallel Bars
Jessica Hutchinson, Denver – Balance Beam
Kiley Rorich, Denver – Uneven Parallel Bars
Jordan Bowers, Oklahoma – All-Around
Audrey Davis, Oklahoma – All-Around
Danielle Sievers, Oklahoma – Vault, Floor
Ragan Smith, Oklahoma – Uneven Parallel Bars
Faith Torrez, Oklahoma – Balance Beam
 
Regular Season WCGA All-Americans
Regular season All-America honors are based on an individual’s final National Qualifying Score (NQS) prior to NCAA regional competition.
 
First Team
Jordan Bowers, Oklahoma – All-Around, Balance Beam, Floor
Katherine LeVasseur, Oklahoma – Vault
Danielle Sievers, Oklahoma – Vault
Audrey Davis, Oklahoma – Uneven Parallel Bars
Ragan Smith, Oklahoma – Balance Beam
Faith Torrez, Oklahoma – Floor
 
Second Team
Jessica Hutchinson, Denver – All-Around
Jordan Bowers, Oklahoma – Vault, Uneven Parallel Bars